6 M&A Branding Strategies to Increase Organizational Value

Mergers and acquisitions (M&A) are complex processes involving financial and operational considerations and the strategic integration of brands. When two companies merge or one acquires another, their brand identities can play a pivotal role in the success or failure of the union. This post explores six effective branding strategies that can help ensure a successful merger or acquisition, starting with why branding is so crucial in the M&A context.

What is M&A Branding?

It’s safe to say everyone is familiar with brands in modern marketing and business, but it’s important to take a look at branding as a concept to understand its role in a successful M&A. Branding is the process of creating a unique identity for a company, product, or service that differentiates it from competitors. This identity is built through elements including the company’s name, logo, tagline, design, messaging, and overall customer experience. A brand represents what a company offers and what it stands for in the minds of its customers, employees, and other stakeholders.

At its core, branding is about perception. It’s how a company communicates values, promises, and personality to a target audience. Effective branding creates a strong emotional connection with customers, fosters loyalty, and can significantly influence purchasing decisions. Branding in an M&A context becomes even more complex and vital as it involves blending or redefining the identities of two or more entities into a cohesive whole.

Why Branding is Important for M&A

Branding plays a crucial role in the M&A process for several reasons:

• Preserving Value: A company’s brand is often one of its most valuable assets. In a merger or acquisition, protecting and enhancing this value is essential to avoid alienating customers and losing market share.
• Cultural Integration: M&A transactions often involve combining different corporate cultures. A unified brand strategy can help align these cultures and create a shared identity that fosters collaboration and unity.
• Market Perception: How the market perceives the new or merged entity can significantly impact its success. Effective branding can help communicate the benefits of the merger or acquisition to customers, investors, and other stakeholders, ensuring a smooth transition and positive reception.
• Employee Morale: M&A can create uncertainty and anxiety among employees. A clear and consistent brand strategy can help reassure employees about the company’s future direction and their role within it, fostering employee retention during this crucial transition.
• Customer Retention: Maintaining customer loyalty during an M&A is challenging. A well-executed branding strategy can help retain customers by emphasizing continuity, stability, and the enhanced value proposition of the new entity.

6 Standard M&A Branding Strategies

M&A branding strategies typically fall into six primary categories, or M&A brand architectures. Each type of brand architecture is relevant to different aspects of brand management and integration during a merger. The standard approaches to M&A branding strategy architecture include:

1. Brand Retention

With a brand retention strategy, the acquiring company retains its own brand and allows the acquired company to maintain its brand identity. This strategy is often used when both brands have strong market recognition and value in their respective markets. It’s also common when companies operate in different sectors or serve distinct customer bases.

Example: Procter & Gamble’s acquisition of Gillette, where both brands continue to operate independently under their own names.

2. Brand Merger

In a branding merger, the two brands are merged into a new, unified brand identity that represents the combined strengths and values of both companies. This approach is common when companies want to create a fresh start or signal a significant change in the market. It is also used when neither brand has a distinct advantage or when the companies want to present a cohesive image post-merger.

Example: The merger of Exxon and Mobil to form ExxonMobil.

3. Brand Absorption

In this M&A branding strategy, the acquiring company’s brand subsumes the acquired company’s brand, effectively eliminating the acquired brand’s identity. This approach is typically employed when the acquiring brand is significantly stronger or has a broader market reach, and the goal is to consolidate market power or streamline brand offerings.

Example: Google’s acquisition of Nest, where Nest products are increasingly marketed under Google’s brand.

4. Rebranding

Full rebranding is when a new brand identity is created for the combined entity, which may involve a new name, logo, and overall brand strategy. Companies may consider rebranding necessary when the existing brands do not align well, when there is a need to distance the new entity from past controversies, or when entering a new market.

Example: The rebranding of Andersen Consulting as Accenture following its split from Arthur Andersen.

5. Brand Endorsement

This is an M&A branding strategy in which the acquired brand is endorsed or co-branded by the acquiring company, and the original brand identity is retained but with an association with the parent company. Brand endorsement is common when the acquired brand has strong equity that the parent company wants to leverage while also introducing its influence. It’s also used when companies wish to maintain some level of brand independence.

Example: Marriott’s acquisition of Starwood Hotels, where Starwood brands like Sheraton and Westin continue to operate with their names but under the Marriott umbrella.

6. Hybrid Branding

The term hybrid branding refers to a mix of different branding strategies where some parts of the acquired brand are absorbed or merged while others are retained or rebranded. This approach is commonly used in complex M&A situations where different business units or product lines have different branding needs.

Example: The merger of Kraft Foods and Heinz, where certain product lines were integrated under the Heinz name while others continued under the Kraft brand.

Each category offers a different approach to managing the brand identities involved in a merger or acquisition. The choice of strategy depends on factors like brand equity, market positioning, the strategic goals of the M&A, and the type of merger and acquisition deal your company is undergoing.

Crucial Steps For Successful M&A Branding Strategies

A successful M&A branding strategy can help both companies successfully integrate and start strong. Following these steps when developing your M&A branding strategy and action plan can pay substantial dividends.

1. Conducting a Brand Audit

Before embarking on any branding strategy during an M&A, it’s crucial to conduct a thorough brand audit of both companies. A brand audit involves evaluating the strengths and weaknesses of each brand, including its market positioning, customer perception, brand equity, and visual identity. This audit will provide valuable insights into how the brands align and where conflicts or synchronization may occur. Understanding these factors will help inform decisions about whether to maintain, merge, or rebrand the entities involved.

2. Defining Brand Architecture

This is where the merging companies will begin to analyze which M&A brand strategy is most appropriate for their unique circumstances. As discussed above, brand architecture refers to the structure of brands within an organization and how they relate to each other. Before embarking on a merger or acquisition, defining the new brand architecture is critical to determining how the new entity will present itself to the market. The right brand architecture will depend on factors such as the strength of the existing brands, market positioning, and strategic goals of the M&A.

3. Creating a Unified Brand Vision

A clear and compelling brand vision is essential for aligning both internal and external stakeholders during an M&A. Effective brand visions should articulate the purpose, values, and long-term goals of the new entity, providing a roadmap for its future direction. The brand vision should resonate with the company’s combined customer base, employees, and partners, serving as a unifying force that guides decision-making and communication. A well-defined brand vision helps create a sense of purpose and continuity, even amid significant change.

4. Developing a Comprehensive Communication Plan

Effective communication is key to managing the brand transition during an M&A. A comprehensive communication plan should outline how and when information about the merger or acquisition will be shared with different audiences, including employees, customers, investors, and the media. The plan should include messaging that addresses potential concerns, emphasizes the benefits of the M&A, and reinforces the new brand identity. Consistent and transparent communication helps build trust and minimizes stakeholder confusion and uncertainty.

5. Leveraging Customer Insights

Understanding customer perceptions and preferences is critical when developing an M&A branding strategy. Conducting surveys, focus groups, and market research can provide valuable insights into what customers value most about each brand and how they feel about the merger or acquisition. These insights can inform decisions about which brand elements to retain, how to communicate the new brand identity, and how to address customers’ concerns. By putting the customer at the center of the branding strategy, companies can ensure a smoother transition and maintain customer loyalty.

6. Aligning Corporate Cultures

Cultural alignment is one of the most challenging aspects of any M&A and plays a significant role in branding. A successful brand reflects a company’s culture, so it’s essential to ensure that the merged or acquired entities share similar values, behaviors, and work environments. To achieve this, companies should engage in cultural due diligence, identify areas of commonality, and address potential conflicts. Creating a shared culture that aligns with the new brand identity will help foster employee engagement, collaboration, and a sense of belonging.

7. Reevaluating Brand Positioning

Brand positioning defines how a company differentiates itself in the market and the value it offers to customers. During an M&A, it’s important to reevaluate the brand positioning to ensure it reflects the new entity’s combined strengths and market opportunities. This may involve refining the brand’s value proposition, identifying new target audiences, and adjusting messaging to highlight the benefits of the merger or acquisition. A strong, differentiated brand positioning can help the new entity stand out in a competitive market and attract new customers.

8. Revitalizing Visual Identity

A brand’s visual identity — including its logo, color scheme, typography, and design elements — plays a crucial role in shaping how it is perceived. During an M&A, companies may update or completely redesign their visual identity to reflect the new brand strategy. This can help signal change, unify the brand, and create a fresh start. However, it’s important to strike a balance between maintaining brand recognition and embracing new visual elements. A well-executed visual identity refresh can enhance the brand’s appeal and ensure consistency across all touchpoints.

9. Focusing on Employee Engagement

Employees are the brand ambassadors of any company, and their buy-in is critical to the success of an M&A branding strategy. Engaging employees in the branding process can help build enthusiasm, reduce resistance to change, and ensure that the new brand identity is embraced at all levels of the organization. This can be achieved through internal communication campaigns, workshops, and training sessions that explain the new brand vision, values, and positioning. Empowering employees to be part of the brand transition will help create a more cohesive and unified workforce.

10. Implementing a Phased Rollout

Launching a new brand identity can be a complex and challenging process, especially in the context of an M&A branding strategy. To manage this transition effectively, companies may opt for a phased rollout of the new brand identity. This approach allows for gradual implementation across different regions, business units, or customer segments, minimizing disruption and allowing time to address any issues that arise. A phased rollout also provides an opportunity to gather feedback and make adjustments before the full launch, ensuring a smoother and more successful brand transition.

11. Monitoring Brand Performance

Brand performance should be continuously monitored throughout the M&A process to ensure that the new brand identity resonates with stakeholders and achieves the desired outcomes. This can be done through regular surveys, social media monitoring, and brand equity tracking. By closely monitoring brand performance metrics, companies can identify areas where the brand may be struggling and take corrective action as needed. Ongoing monitoring also provides valuable insights into the effectiveness of the branding strategy and helps guide future brand initiatives.

12. Planning for Contingencies

Even the best-laid branding strategies can encounter unexpected challenges during an M&A. It’s important to plan for contingencies and have a flexible approach to brand management. This might involve preparing alternative branding scenarios, setting aside resources for potential rebranding efforts, or having a crisis communication plan in place. Being proactive and adaptable can help companies navigate unforeseen obstacles and ensure that the brand remains strong and resilient throughout the M&A process.

Proven M&A Branding Strategy Expertise

Branding is a critical component of any successful merger or acquisition. By taking a strategic approach to brand management, companies can preserve brand value, align corporate cultures, and create a unified identity that resonates with stakeholders. The strategies outlined in this guide provide a roadmap for navigating the complexities of M&A branding, helping companies achieve a smooth transition and maximize the benefits of their merger or acquisition. A strong and cohesive brand can be the key to unlocking long-term success and growth in an increasingly competitive market.

Comments